Writing about Writing

I’d like to share a few thoughts about John Williams‘ novel ‘Stoner’. There is an intensity and a terrifying sense of claustrophobia in this extraordinary novel. It is of course a tragedy, As such Stoner’s journey is inevitable – but no less moving for that. That he seeks love and eventually both finds and loses it is to be expected – what is not expected is the quality if the prose. There is an attention to evocative detail and the experience of ‘place’ that is truly beautiful. One feels that every word has been carefully judged and made a servant to the purpose of enmeshing us, trapping us, within the life within which Stoner acquiesces, fights, survives and surrenders. It is a profoundly sad book – it made me weep. But is is also a book that celebrates the human spirit and its refusal to bend to an idiotic world. I suppose it’s also a book that makes me think – ‘no bloody way’ – and that’s good, even though, unlike Stoner, I’m not trapped as he is.


I’ve recently finished reading William McIlvanney’s ‘Laidlaw’ trilogy. He’s regarded as the ‘founder’ of Scottish ‘noire’ crime fiction – this may be so but he’s much more important than that. The quality and detail of his imaginative writing is wonderful. His observation and humour are compelling and his depiction of a world unseen by the casual visitor to Scotland’s past and present is a revelation. In the first 2 volumes (‘Laidlaw’ & ‘The Papers of Tony Veitch’) of the trilogy the hero – Laidlaw – is viewed from an objective point of view with an all seeing and understanding narrator. The third volume – ‘Strange Loyalties’ – is written from Laidlaw’s own perspective. The shift, at first, is disorienting but ultimately utterly satisfying and increases the potency of the first two books. McIlvanney’s writing in these 3 books should not be missed – not just by fans of detective fiction but all those who enjoy the very best of contemporary fiction whatever the genre.

Quotations – answers

“Arguing with a dead man in a lavatory is a claustrophobic experience.” Ian McEwan in ‘Sweet Tooth’.

“Writing is my chief means of communicating with myself …” Elizabeth Jane Howard.

“Interesting verbs are seldom interesting.” Jonathan Franzen.

“No one reads a book to get to the middle.” Mickey Spillane.

‘Be your own editor/critic. Sympathetic but merciless!’ Joyce Carol Oates

“Mind is like a parachute – it doesn’t work if it’s not open.” Frank Zappa

” … a snail licks a thousand tits gushing the pope-king’s blue piss …: Joan Miro 1938 – being part of the title of a painting

“Nothing thicker than a knife’s blade separates happiness from melancholy.” Virginia Woolf “Orlando”

“The Church is a dead telephone; even though the people know better, they pick it up and listen.” Martin Cruz Smith “Tatiana”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s